RrRental
Resilience
Start here
Learn by evaluating

The Deal Lab

Follow the evidence. Follow the cash.

Guided evaluation steps →
Fictional example. Editing creates an example variation; your personal draft stays separate. Saved in this browser only.
STR / LTR cash flowAfter replacement funding · per year$11,738 / -$12,410Decision summary →
Your working decision record

The coastal cottage

October 28, 2026 · STR & LTR · USD

Fictional example assumptions. No inputs are independently verified. Scenario outcomes are not a purchase recommendation or a maximum possible loss.

What supports this case

STR base budget leaves cash after replacement funding

$11,738 per year remains under the entered assumptions. Confirm income and costs with property-specific evidence.

STR acquisition fits your entered cash budget

Modeled upfront cash is $153,750, leaving $6,250 of headroom within that budget.

LTR acquisition fits your entered cash budget

Modeled upfront cash is $131,750, leaving $28,250 of headroom within that budget.

What needs attention

STR scenario crosses your reserve floor

Lowest modeled cash: $8,970. Your floor: $10,000.

LTR base budget needs cash support

The annual deficit is $12,410 after replacement funding. Explore whether different terms or a supported operating change can improve the fit.

LTR scenario exceeds your annual deficit limit

Modeled shortfall: $25,141. Your limit: $15,000.

LTR needs additional cash in this scenario

At least $1,541 additional cash would avoid a negative modeled month-end balance, before any extra cushion.

LTR scenario crosses your reserve floor

Lowest modeled cash: -$1,541. Your floor: $10,000.

The connected alternative crosses your floor

First breach at month 3; lowest cash -$8,500. $18,500 additional starting cash would maintain your floor in this modeled sequence.

The LTR alternative needs ongoing cash support

Annual cash flow after replacement funding is -$12,410. Investigate whether this alternative fits your resources before relying on it.

Base financial comparison

Short-term rental cash flow
$11,738
Annual · after replacement funding
Long-term rental cash flow
-$12,410
Annual · after replacement funding

Follow the money · annual

Annual breakdownSTRLTR
Collected operating income$77,350$28,500
Revenue & night-based costs$23,622$3,420
Fixed operating expenses$16,500$12,000
Net operating income · explain

Collected operating income minus operating expenses, before loan payments, income taxes, depreciation and capital replacements. In this site’s model, $50,000 income less $20,000 operating costs gives $30,000 NOI.

$37,229$13,080
Loan principal & interest · explain

The loan repayment plus interest. The Deal Lab models fixed-rate amortizing debt. Enter taxes and property insurance separately in operating costs, even if the lender collects them through escrow. Account for other loan charges separately.

$21,890$21,890
Replacement allocation · explain

Money you plan to set aside for major components such as a roof or HVAC system. It reduces modeled distributable cash, but an internal transfer does not reduce consolidated property cash. Actual repairs or replacements do.

$3,600$3,600
Cash flow after allocation · explain

In this site, NOI minus loan principal and interest and planned replacement funding. This is a pre-tax planning amount, not a total investment return.

$11,738-$12,410
Cash required at purchase (one time)$153,750$131,750
Cap rate (annual) · explain

Annual NOI divided by purchase price in this model. It describes operating income relative to price before financing; it does not include appreciation or sale proceeds.

9.9%3.5%
Cash-on-cash return (annual) · explain

Here, annual cash flow after replacement funding divided by down payment, closing costs, setup and starting reserve. $2,400 divided by $100,000 is 2.4%. Other tools may count invested cash differently.

7.6%-9.4%

Monthly averages are annual amounts divided by 12, not a month-by-month forecast. Acquisition cash includes down payment, closing, setup and reserves.

What does break-even require?

Annual breakdownSTRLTR
Paid-night occupancy53.1%—
Monthly lease rent—$3,737

Covers operating costs, debt and replacement funding. Occupancy above 100% is unattainable with these inputs. No appreciation, tax benefits or sale proceeds are included.

Downside outcomes

Annual breakdownSTRLTR
Annual deficit/surplus after repair & replacement-$13,141-$25,141
Lowest modeled cash, including starting reserve$8,970-$1,541

Connected STR-to-LTR fallback

Cash after 12 stressed STR months: $10,459. The transition uses $10,148, leaving $311 at LTR opening. After 12 base LTR months: -$8,500. Ongoing LTR cash flow after replacement funding: -$12,410/year.

Options to explore

  • Investigate the strongest case. Use the source checklist to confirm the income, operating costs, permissions and condition behind it.
  • Test terms one at a time. A different purchase price changes debt and upfront cash; a different management plan changes both costs and responsibilities. Record what would make each change achievable.
  • Separate liquidity from profitability. More reserves can support the cash timeline, but do not improve operating cash flow. A higher rent assumption needs evidence, not just a better result.
  • Choose a next step that fits. Continue diligence, revise the plan, compare another strategy, or look for a different property. Record the reason in your decision notes.
Explore a revised budget →

What needs more evidence

7 of 7 research areas still need a reviewed quote/document and a source note. Statuses are your labels; this count does not validate a source.

Rental permission · Unknown · Needs review

Next action: Address-specific official source, jurisdiction, permit eligibility and transferability.

HOA & loan restrictions · Unknown · Needs review

Next action: Current association documents and written lender confirmation of intended use.

STR income comparables · Unknown · Needs review

Next action: Record comparable paid-night rates, available nights, occupancy definitions, seasonality, dates and property differences. Save a conservative range.

LTR lease comparables · Unknown · Needs review

Next action: Record comparable achieved lease rents, concessions, owner-paid utilities, days to lease, dates and property differences. Ask a local manager for written support.

Insurance & property taxes · Unknown · Needs review

Next action: Rental-use quote, exclusions/deductible and purchase-specific tax estimate.

Condition & full operating budget · Unknown · Needs review

Next action: Inspection, repair/replacement quotes, management terms and utilities.

Fallback feasibility · Unknown · Needs review

Next action: LTR demand and permission, transition costs and leasing-time evidence.

Unknown-input research queue

No missing numerical inputs in the selected evaluation. Numeric completeness is not evidence quality.

Your constraints & decision notes

Maximum acquisition cash budget: 160000 $

Available operating time: 8 hours/week

Minimum reserve floor: 10000 $

Maximum annual cash-flow deficit: 15000 $

Record whether to investigate further, revise assumptions, or pass—and why.

Time capacity is recorded, not scored. Confirm actual workload and management coverage separately.

Inputs used in this evaluation
InputValue
Purchase price375000 $
Down payment25 %
Fixed interest rate6.75 %
Loan term30 years
Closing costs12000 $
Starting cash reserve20000 $
STR setup & launch28000 $
Average nightly rate325 $
Paid-night occupancy68 %
Available nights350 per year
STR platform fee3 %
STR Management fee20 %
STR Routine maintenance allowance2 %
STR cost per occupied night18 $
STR Property tax5500 $/year
STR Rental insurance3600 $/year
STR Owner-paid utilities3600 $/year
STR HOA / association dues1800 $/year
STR permits & licenses600 $/year
STR Other annual operating costs1400 $/year
STR replacement funding3600 $/year
STR Previous combined fee allowance0 %
STR Previous combined fixed costs0 $/year
LTR setup & launch6000 $
Monthly lease rent2500 $
LTR income lost to vacancy5 %
LTR Management fee8 %
LTR Routine maintenance allowance4 %
LTR Property tax5500 $/year
LTR Rental insurance2200 $/year
LTR Owner-paid utilities1200 $/year
LTR HOA / association dues1800 $/year
LTR recurring leasing allowance900 $/year
LTR Other annual operating costs400 $/year
LTR replacement funding3600 $/year
LTR Previous combined fee allowance0 %
LTR Previous combined fixed costs0 $/year
Fixed & per-night cost increase10 %
One-time repair7500 $
Repair month3 1–12
STR nightly-rate decline10 %
STR occupied-night decline20 %
LTR rent decline8 %
Extra LTR lost rent1 months
Switch after stressed STR operation12 months
Conversion downtime2 months
One-time conversion costs4500 $
Maximum acquisition cash budget160000 $
Available operating time8 hours/week
Minimum reserve floor10000 $
Maximum annual cash-flow deficit15000 $

Model boundaries

Pre-tax, fixed amortizing debt. No appreciation, tax benefits, sale proceeds, refinancing or probabilities. Month-end cash can miss intramonth shortfalls. STR seasonality is illustrative; LTR vacancy is smoothed. Planned replacement funding reduces distributable cash but stays in consolidated cash until spent. The connected fallback uses a stressed STR period followed by base LTR assumptions. These are not guaranteed loss limits.

THE RENTAL RESILIENCE LETTER

Get new breakdowns by email.

One rental question, one worked example, one useful next step.

Read the journal →