RENTAL RESILIENCE · Commentary
Rentals are hot. So why the freebies?
Published 2026-10-18 · Rental Resilience · Developed with AI assistance
From Rental Resilience
Practical rental education
More rental interest sounds great. The interesting part is what landlords still have to offer to win a tenant.
If you own a rental, “demand is up” sounds like the opening line of a very good day. Maybe the place fills faster. Maybe the asking rent finally feels reasonable. Maybe you can stop checking the listing every twenty minutes.
Then someone down the street offers a move-in special.
That’s the tension worth watching in Zillow’s September rent report.
The headline and the catch
Zillow’s rental-demand index rose 19.2% year over year in September 2026. That index measures smoothed engagement with Zillow rental listings; it does not mean 19.2% more signed leases. National asking rents rose a much smaller 2.7% year over year. Meanwhile, 39.6% of rentals on Zillow offered concessions. See Zillow’s October 15 report and its rental-demand index definition.
Interest is useful. It doesn’t automatically give every owner pricing power. And “concession” can mean different incentives, not necessarily a free month.
Three bets I’d watch
These are our working hypotheses for the next 6–12 months, not Zillow forecasts or promises.
1. The freebie may outlive the hot headline
Where tenants have plenty of comparable choices, I expect owners to keep competing with incentives. A busy open house is encouraging; a signed lease at a sustainable price is what pays the bills. This view would weaken if nearby availability dropped and incentives started disappearing.
2. A useful home could beat a fancy upgrade
My bet is that a clean, reliable property with the right layout, parking and location can compete without chasing the most expensive finishes. Test that hypothesis with local comparable listings and leasing feedback. It is no reason to skip repairs or assume any house will rent.
3. The biggest mistake may happen before the tenant arrives
I expect some buyers to pay too much because a strong demand headline makes future rent increases feel inevitable. If the purchase only works after several generous raises, you have bought a forecast with a roof on it. Better local rents could prove that caution too conservative; I would still want the current numbers to carry their share of the argument.
The free-month test
Here is an invented example, not a market forecast: a property advertises $2,400 a month and gives one month free on a 12-month lease. It collects $26,400 for that year, or $2,200 per month averaged across the lease, before expenses. The listing still says $2,400. Your bank account notices the difference.
Try your prospective purchase with flat rents and one concession month, then layer in realistic operating costs, debt service, repairs and reserves. Model vacancy separately; a free month on an occupied lease is not the same as a vacant month. Avoid counting the same rent loss twice.
If that scenario is comfortable, you have something worth investigating. If it is tight, negotiate using actual local evidence. If it only survives because next year is magically better, keep looking.
What I’d do before making an offer
Pull comparable rentals of the same property type, check incentives and time on market, and ask a local manager what actually leases. Get property-specific insurance and repair estimates. Run the case with today’s achievable rent before giving tomorrow’s growth any credit.
For a vacation rental, this report is background, not evidence for nightly rates or booked nights. Underwrite STR demand separately.
Bottom line: I like stronger interest as a reason to investigate. I like a purchase that survives a less exciting year even more.
Run your own flat-rent scenario in the rental cash-flow calculator.
Related reading: More room to negotiate. What price makes the rental work?
Educational material. Examples are illustrative; positive cash flow alone does not establish whether an investment fits your goals.
Calculation methodology →